Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
by 
Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Caldwell
Stay where you never have to explain yourself
Stays near Caldwell
These stays match your search but are located outside Caldwell.
Hosted by Ryan
Instant booking
Instant bookingEntire place • 3.7 miles from Caldwell
4.86 (1)
4BR/2BA Duplex Apt in Downtown Montclair w/Parking
4 Bedrooms • 4 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Hosted by Ryan
Instant booking
Entire place • 3.7 miles from Caldwell
4.52 (1)
Downtown Montclair | 2BR Apt | Parking & Train Nearby
2 Bedrooms • 2 Beds • 1 Bathroom
97Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#1 Hotel
Hotel *** • 16.2 miles from Caldwell
Booked 78 times
4.84 (76)
West Side YMCA
18 min · Industry Bar (Gay Bars & Clubs)Wi-Fi • Pool • Spa
Alan·5·Sep. 2025· "Great staff; great mix of guests - nice vibe; loved gym access, Central Park access, Columbus Circle - the whole community. Bed was comfortable....sheets and blanket fresh as well as towels. Everything was clean but the age made fixtures feel run down. But i will stay here again. Loved the vibe of the place."
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#2 Hotel
Hotel *** • 16.4 miles from Caldwell
Booked 45 times
4.98 (45)
HI New York City Hostel
10 min · Suite (Gay Bars & Clubs)Wi-Fi • Bar • Elevator
Saul·5·Sep. 2025· "This place is awesome. The rooms are very clean, the bed was comfortable, clean bathrooms, and great fun amenities. But besides that, I will be back here."
98Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#3 Hotel
Hotel *** • 15.9 miles from Caldwell
Booked 35 times
4.91 (35)
Pod Times Square
7 min · 9th Avenue Saloon (Gay Bars & Clubs)Gay District • Wi-Fi • Parking
Allen·5·May. 2025· "Convenient hotel near Times Square"
98Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#4 Hotel
Hotel *** • 18.3 miles from Caldwell
Booked 8 times
4.88 (8)
The Local NY Hostel
Wi-Fi • Bar
Cwilliam·5·May. 2026· "Pleasant staff, easy to get to, no hassle."
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Hotel • 16.9 miles from Caldwell
Booked 5 times
5 (5)
The Nolita Express Hostel
8 min · The Cock (Gay Bars & Clubs)Wi-Fi
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Private room **** • 13.9 miles from Caldwell
Booked 1 time
5 (1)
Comfy apt with skyline front view Mins away from NYC
Wi-Fi • Parking
Chris·5·Jul. 2026· "Jimmy's place is at a great location. He was very responsive and the process to check in was very easy. Will definitely be coming back."
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 17.1 miles from Caldwell
Booked 4 times
5 (4)
Pod 51
9 min · East Side Club (Gay Saunas & Cruising)Wi-Fi • Parking • Pets allowed
93Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Hotel **** • 16.3 miles from Caldwell
Booked 6 times
4.67 (6)
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
4 min · Big Apple Ranch (Gay Bars & Clubs)Wi-Fi • Parking • Gym
Jesús·4·Aug. 2022· "Amazing location, walking distance to any Broadway theater. Housekeeping was always on the watch and very willing to help. Gladly during my week stay I only had one awful interaction with the person at the front desk. They were very patronizing and even made me feel uncomfortable, as if I didn't understand proper English. Other than that a lovely experience."
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Private room • 13 miles from Caldwell
Booked 2 times
5 (2)
20 min NYC-Modern Private Room-Queen Bed-Parking Available But Confirm with Hosts
Wi-Fi • Parking
Dave·5·Jun. 2026· "This place is a good deal for the money, very close to NYC. Very easy self check in/out. This is definitely a place to return to."
80Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Hotel * • 15.9 miles from Caldwell
Booked 6 times
4 (5)
Lamartine Chelsea
12 min · Snaxx (Gay Bars & Clubs)Wi-Fi • Adult Only • Parking
Michael·4·Mar. 2026· "Room was small but fine. Barely had room for my luggage. There was only one electrical plug accessible. Overall fine for what paid. I got there an hour early and wanted to check in but the guy made me wait 3pm."