Home / Gay Accommodations and B&bs in United States / Gay Accommodations and B&bs in Fire Island Pines

Search Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Fire Island Pines

Pleaseselect datesto see availability and prices

See Ranking criteria

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Private room • 11.9 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 4.94 (18)

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Private room • 8 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (5)

Rooms near beach and train to NYC

Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

Entire place • Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (3)

The poolhouse at Shady Walk

Gay District • Hot tub • Pets allowed

#1 Hotel

Welcoming

Approval

Instant

Hotel *** • 1.2 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (4)

Grove Hotel

🏆 Pride Points x2

Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only

Seaclusion Gardens

Seaclusion Gardens

Seaclusion Gardens

Seaclusion Gardens

Seaclusion Gardens

Approval

Instant

Entire place • 4.7 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ New

Seaclusion Gardens

Gay District • Air conditioning • Kitchen

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Shared space: bedroom • 11.9 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 4.5 (2)

Clothing Optional: Cozy room near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Robbins Rest Retreat

Robbins Rest Retreat

Robbins Rest Retreat

Robbins Rest Retreat

Robbins Rest Retreat

Approval

Instant

Entire place • 5.2 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ New

Robbins Rest Retreat

Gay District • Pets allowed • Air conditioning

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Private room • 8 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal

Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning

The Surfcomber Unit 2

The Surfcomber Unit 2

The Surfcomber Unit 2

The Surfcomber Unit 2

The Surfcomber Unit 2

Approval

Instant

Entire place • 3.8 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ New

The Surfcomber Unit 2

Gay District • Pets allowed • Air conditioning

Welcoming

The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines

Approval

Instant

Private room • Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (2)

The Madison Fire Island Pines

🏆 Pride Points x0.5

Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Approval

Instant

Entire place • 3.8 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ New

Poolside Chic by the Sea

Gay District • Air conditioning • Kitchen

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Entire place • Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views

Gay District • Air conditioning • Kitchen

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Approval

Instant

Entire place • 3.7 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ New

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Gay District • Pets allowed • Air conditioning

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Entire place • Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

Stay at Daddy’s House!!

Gay District • Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Private room • 1.1 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room

Gay District • Breakfast included • Hot tub

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

Private room • 5.1 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Private room • 10 miles from Fire Island Pines

★ 5 (1)

Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********

Clothing optional accepted • Breakfast included • Parking