Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
by 
Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in West Sayville
Stay where you never have to explain yourself
Hosted by SkieLikes Musicals, Disco, Exhibitions & Museums
Happy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Private room • West Sayville
2025 Summer Rentals, Fire Island Pines
4 min · Pines Bistro & Martini Bar (Gay Restaurants)Gay District • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Continue scrolling to discover more options.
Stays near West Sayville
These stays match your search but are located outside West Sayville.
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Instant bookingEntire place • 6.4 miles from West Sayville
4.9 (1)
Seaclusion Gardens in Ocean Beach
4 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 5.8 miles from West Sayville
4.85 (1)
Poolside Oasis in Ocean Bay
3 Bedrooms • 6 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 6 miles from West Sayville
4.81 (1)
Huron Hideaway in Ocean Bay
3 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 1 Bathroom
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 6 miles from West Sayville
4.62 (1)
Seaside Escape on Huron
5 Bedrooms • 7 Beds • 1 Bathroom
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#1 Hotel
Hotel *** • 4.7 miles from West Sayville
Booked 4 times
5 (4)
Grove Hotel
19 min · Fire Island (Gay Beaches)Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#2 Hotel
Hotel *** • 18.6 miles from West Sayville
Booked 1 time
5 (1)
Best Western Bar Harbour Inn
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Entire place • 12.1 miles from West Sayville
4.88 (1)
Kaikay's Home, 20 minutes from Beaches &WaterPark
1 Bedroom • 2 Beds • 1 Bathroom
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 5.8 miles from West Sayville
4.68 (1)
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Wi-Fi • Parking • Smoking allowed
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 5.8 miles from West Sayville
4.84 (1)
Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel ** • 18.2 miles from West Sayville
4.64 (1)
Chalet Inn & Suites
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Entire place • 11.8 miles from West Sayville
4.96 (1)
Private Apt King Suite, L.I, NY-Hamptons to NYC
1 Bedroom • 2 Beds • 1 Bathroom