Ā by 
I have always thought Key West is the most openly gay small city in America - not the largest scene by any measure, but the most fully committed to LGBTQ+ welcome at every level, from the police department to the hotel check-in desk. The three gay hotels in Key West our community books most are Southernmost Inn Adult Exclusive, Blue Marlin Motel, and Eden House - all in or near the Pink Triangle on Duval Street, and all rated by the misterb&b gay community for the kind of welcome that makes Key West unlike anywhere else. With 7 gay bars and 8 gay-friendly restaurants listed on misterb&b, Key West is as complete a gay destination as it gets. For the best local knowledge, booking through misterb&b is always recommended. 🏳️🌈
misterb&b exclusive data - LGBTQ+ travelers in Key West 2026
misterb&b data - Gay Hotels Key West - 2026
| Best gay neighborhood for LGBTQ+ stays | The Pink Triangle - Duval Street, 7 bars, 8 restaurants |
| Peak gay hotel booking months | October (Fantasy Fest), December-April (winter season), June (Pride) |
| LGBTQ+ non-discrimination charter | 100% of listed properties - mandatory condition of listing |
| Best availability / lowest prices | August-September (hot, slow season) |
Venue counts: misterb&b platform data, April 2026.
Best gay-friendly hotels in Key West - misterb&b community's choice 2026
Key West's most-booked LGBTQ+-friendly property on misterb&b. An adults-only boutique inn in the heart of Old Town, consistently rated at the top of the Key West misterb&b community for its tropical atmosphere, pool, and the kind of welcoming environment that makes Key West legendary.
96% recommended by the misterb&b gay community
The highest-rated property in the Key West top 3 on misterb&b. Blue Marlin Motel is a classic Key West motel with a loyal gay following, pool, and a location that puts you steps from the Pink Triangle gay district. Rated at the absolute top of the Key West community for value and atmosphere.
97% recommended by the misterb&b gay community - highest in Key West top 3
A boutique guesthouse with a long Key West history and strong LGBTQ+ credentials. Eden House is known for its relaxed, adults-oriented atmosphere, hammocks, pool, and genuinely warm welcome - everything that makes Key West guesthouses different from hotels anywhere else.
93% recommended by the misterb&b gay community
Connect with Key West's LGBTQ+ community. Join weere by misterb&b - meet locals, plan Fantasy Fest, or find community activities on the island. 🏳️🌈
When to book your gay hotel in Key West
Key West has three distinct peaks: Key West Pride in June, Fantasy Fest in October, and the winter season from December through April. All three require booking 4 to 8 weeks ahead. August and September are the quietest and most affordable. The gay parties Key West calendar runs year-round.
The Pink Triangle - Key West's gay district
The The Pink Triangle on lower Duval Street is Key West's gay heart - 7 gay bars and 8 gay-friendly restaurants in a compact, walkable area. The full scene is on the gay map Key West. The Key West safety guide confirms this is one of the safest US destinations for LGBTQ+ travelers. For private hosted stays, gay BnB Key West on misterb&b has local hosts.
What gay travelers ask before booking Key West
| Is Key West gay-friendly? | Yes - Key West is arguably the most openly gay city in the US. Same-sex couples are completely welcome everywhere on the island. |
| What is Fantasy Fest? | Key West's famous October festival - 10 days of LGBTQ+-friendly parties, parades, and events. One of the US's biggest adult celebrations. |
| Gay BnB in Key West? | Gay BnB Key West on misterb&b for private hosted stays with local knowledge. |
| Nearby Florida gay cities? | Gay hotels Miami (4h north), gay hotels Fort Lauderdale (4.5h). |
Why LGBTQ+ travelers book their Key West gay hotel on misterb&b
Every property on misterb&b has signed a non-discrimination charter. Key West is part of a Florida network that includes gay hotels Miami, gay hotels Fort Lauderdale and gay hotels Orlando. For the full Key West picture, see the Gay Guide Key West.
Explore more of gay Key West
FAQ - Gay Hotels Key West
What are the best gay hotels in Key West?
The three top-ranked LGBTQ+-friendly hotels in Key West on misterb&b are Southernmost Inn Adult Exclusive, Blue Marlin Motel, and Eden House. All three are in or near the Pink Triangle gay district on Duval Street.
Is Key West gay-friendly?
Key West is one of the most LGBTQ+-welcoming cities in the United States and arguably the most openly gay small city in America. The city has celebrated its gay community openly since the 1970s. Same-sex couples are completely welcome throughout.
What is the gay area in Key West?
The Pink Triangle on lower Duval Street is Key West's main LGBTQ+ neighborhood, with 7 gay bars listed on misterb&b. The area is walkable and the gay scene extends throughout the historic Old Town.
How much do gay hotels in Key West cost?
Gay hotels in Key West range from around USD 100 for budget motels to USD 300+ for boutique guesthouses. Fantasy Fest in October and winter season (December-April) are peak periods with highest prices.
When is Key West Gay Pride?
Key West Pride takes place in June. The city also hosts Fantasy Fest in October - a major LGBTQ+-friendly event that is one of Key West's biggest annual celebrations.
Does Key West have a gay neighborhood?
Yes. The Pink Triangle on lower Duval Street is Key West's gay district with 7 gay bars and 8 gay-friendly restaurants listed on misterb&b.
Is misterb&b available for hotels in Key West?
Yes. misterb&b lists LGBTQ+-friendly hotels and private hosted stays in Key West. The top 3 are Southernmost Inn Adult Exclusive, Blue Marlin Motel, and Eden House.
Sources: misterb&b platform data, 2026. Venue counts: misterb&b internal platform data, April 2026.
Instant booking
, misterb&b's social hub, available with any hotel booking.
Happy to share local tips
