Home / United States / Whitefish Bay

Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Whitefish Bay

Stay where you never have to explain yourself

Hosted by RyanLikes Football, Basketball, Biking

Private room • Whitefish Bay

Booked 12 times

5 (10)

Charming Whitefish Bay bungalow

LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby • Parking

Terp·5·Mar. 2026· "Staying with Ryan was great! He was a friendly and communicative host, who made sure I had everything I needed to be comfortable in his home. We even hung out and watched a bit of TV together. The house is easy to get to and very cozy. It was the perfect home base I needed for the work I was doing this weekend. I'd definitely stay here again."

Continue scrolling to discover more options.

Keep searching in the city: Trusted gay-friendly stays

Gay travel is a niche market, which is why our inventory here is sometimes limited. By booking one of these LGBTQ+ friendly stays, you directly help misterb&b fund its mission: recruiting new gay hosts and covering the complex legal and regulatory costs we face. Give your stay meaning - book your favorite below!

Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.

Instant booking

Entire place • Whitefish Bay

Robin's Bluff

1 Bedroom • 2 Beds • 1 Bathroom

Continue scrolling to discover more options.

Stays near Whitefish Bay

These stays match your search but are located outside Whitefish Bay.

Gay Welcoming Score

Rated by LGBTQ+ travelers

Instant booking

Private room ***** • 5.8 miles from Whitefish Bay

Booked 2 times

4 (1)

Schuster Mansion Bed & Breakfast

Breakfast included • Wi-Fi • Parking

Gay Welcoming Score

Rated by LGBTQ+ travelers

SpringHill Suites by Marriott Milwaukee Downtown

Instant booking

Ranked#1 Hotel

Hotel *** • 5.1 miles from Whitefish Bay

Booked 2 times

4.5 (2)

SpringHill Suites by Marriott Milwaukee Downtown

Wi-Fi • Parking • Gym

James·4·Jun. 2023· "This place is the "new" kind of ******** (or Misterb&b) in that it's not someone's home or second home. It's a hotel-apartment building where the "host" owns several units and rents them out. This particular room was disappointing for several reasons. There is no closet (no place to hang clothes); the plug for the coffee maker didn't work, and the drain in the very tiny bathroom sink backed up immediately. And even though it's really a hotel, no one came to clean the room or make the bed. The only good things about staying here were (1) it was quiet and (2) the breakfast was good. The neighborhood is very depressing--Upper Midwest post-industrial wreck. I would not stay here again."

100

Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers