misterb&b logo
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"Become a host
PrideGay Hotels
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Mark
Response rate: 50% • Response time: < 12h
Happy to share local tips

C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room

Sayville, NY, United StatesLGBTQ+ venues nearbyMap
Exceptional5.0(1)Booked once
Private room
2 guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
1 bed
Clothing optional acceptedHappy to share local tipsLGBTQ+ venues nearbyWi-FiBreakfast includedPoolHot tubParking

The Reveal

Come As You Are Inn B&B (Bed and Breakfast) Serving The LGBTQ Community - Gay Owned & Operated And Bloody Proud Love Is Love

At Come As You Are Inn, we welcome you to visit us at our Long Island gay B&B for ‘an experience’ which will include food, libations and live piano music.

********

How the beds work

Bedroom1 Queen Bed

Little Luxuries

Clothing optional accepted
Happy to share local tips
LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Wi-Fi
Breakfast included
Pool
Hot tub
Parking
Air conditioning
The Classics
Wi-Fi
Pool
Breakfast included
Air conditioning
Washer
Essentials
Hair dryer
Dryer
Iron
Heating
Hot tub
Outdoor dining area
Parking
LGBTQ+ Favorites
LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Happy to share local tips
Adult Only
Spa salon nearby
Welcome
Smoking allowed
Clothing optional accepted
My location
Near beach
Countryside
Near cultural venues
Fire protection
Smoke alarm
Carbon monoxide alarm
Fire extinguisher

Meet Your Proud Host

Mark5.0(1 review)
E-mail verifiedPhone verifiedID verified
Member sinceJuly 2018
Response rate50%
Response time< 12h
I am a mature, gay male (married/same gender) - occupation; musician/pipe organist and choirmaster Live in a gay-resort area, nearby Fire Island, NY
View profile
8 interests: Diva Legends / Classical / Disco / Jazz / Latin Music / Pop / Rock / World Music

Protect your payments: never communicate outside of misterb&b (website or app) and never transfer money outside our secure system.

Select the dates of your stay

No dates selected yet.

September 2026
SMTWTFS
October 2026
SMTWTFS

Why Book Proud with misterb&b?

Travel with purpose. Support the LGBTQ+ community with every stay.
Your discretion is guaranteed
Your invoice and bank statement never show misterb&b.On your statement:PinkLab
Every stay gives back to the community
This booking will contribute to our Mister for Good program, helping LGBTQ+ NGOs around the world.
Built by and for the LGBTQ+ community
We're an LGBTQ+-owned platform. Your support directly funds jobs and livelihoods for our LGBTQ+ team.
Unlock the local gay scene
Meet LGBTQ+ locals with weere, discover insider tips and explore beyond your hotel.

Where It's All Happening

Sayville, NY, United StatesExact location disclosed after booking only.
LGBTQ+ Safety Score: Sayville
5out of 5Very safeRated by 1 local misterb&b members

Nearby Attractions

Come As You Are Inn is situated in a convenient location - in proximity to the departure point for the Fire Island Ferries to Cherry Grove and The Pines. The house is a short walk from the Sayville Long Island Railroad Train Station, two blocks from downtown Sayville, and a brisk 20 minute walk to the Ferries!

Our Neighborhood: Sayville, New York is a charming hamlet in the town of Islip. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, it is about one hour from Manhattan, Penn Station, and approximately one hour to the air-trains to JFK International Airport. Also, our house is a ten minute drive from MacArthur Airport. In addition to shopping on Main Street, you will find golf at a number of nearby courses, a small beach and park by the Bay, and the Loughlin Vineyard tucked away on the Roosevelt Estate.

House Rules & Conditions

Check-infrom 1pm to 9pm
Checkoutto 11am
Host recommendations

Check-in time: 1:00pm Check-out time: 11:00am No pets (including service animals). We have but only 3 rental units and so are not obligated by law - moreover, there does happen to be a medical condition by the owner who is highly allergic to both cats and dogs - apologies

Minimum stay (nights)1 night

1 night

DepositNot required by the Host

Not required by the Host

Cancellation Policy

Terms of Services & Privacy Policy apply to this transaction.

Add dates to get the cancellation details

ReviewsExceptional5(1)

Reviews come from verified guests, are sorted chronologically and not subjected to prior monitoring.

Cleanliness5.0
Location5.0
Accurate description5.0
Check-in5.0
Value for money5.0

Our Community Has Spoken:

JoshuaStayed in June 2023
Reviewed on June 28, 2023

Perfect, quiet getaway before/during/after a trip to Fire Island. Very close to the ferry station. Don't stay at the chain hotels when you can support the local small businesses

Mark's other accommodations

More gay B&Bs in Sayville

Exceptional5.0(1)