Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
by 
Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Shirley
Stay where you never have to explain yourself
Happy to share local tips
Booked 30 times
4.94 (18)
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Clothing optional accepted • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Michael John·5·Jul. 2025· "Vincent and Jose were great hosts! They also had a very sweet canine ambassador representing the house. The space was perfect: nice size room, updated private bathroom, great back yard with a hot tub and a small above-ground pool, bed was comfy, and I was very well taken care of during my stay. I would definitely stay again and encourage others do the same."
Continue scrolling to discover more options.
Keep searching in the city: Trusted gay-friendly stays
Gay travel is a niche market, which is why our inventory here is sometimes limited. By booking one of these LGBTQ+ friendly stays, you directly help misterb&b fund its mission: recruiting new gay hosts and covering the complex legal and regulatory costs we face. Give your stay meaning - book your favorite below!
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Instant bookingEntire place • Shirley
4.8 (1)
Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less than 5 minutes to the beach!
3 Bedrooms • 4 Beds • 1 Bathroom
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Entire place • Shirley
1 Block to Bellport Bay! Scenic Hamptons Hideaway
3 Bedrooms • 4 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Continue scrolling to discover more options.
Stays near Shirley
These stays match your search but are located outside Shirley.
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 18.5 miles from Shirley
4.9 (1)
Seaclusion Gardens in Ocean Beach
4 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 7.8 miles from Shirley
4.89 (1)
Dune Road House on Westhampton Beach
3 Bedrooms • 8 Beds • 3 Bathrooms
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 17.6 miles from Shirley
4.85 (1)
Poolside Oasis in Ocean Bay
3 Bedrooms • 6 Beds • 2 Bathrooms
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 17.9 miles from Shirley
4.81 (1)
Huron Hideaway in Ocean Bay
3 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 1 Bathroom
Hosted by Benjamin
Instant booking
Entire place • 17.9 miles from Shirley
4.62 (1)
Seaside Escape on Huron
5 Bedrooms • 7 Beds • 1 Bathroom
100Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers
Instant booking
Ranked#1 Hotel
Hotel *** • 15.2 miles from Shirley
Booked 4 times
5 (4)
Grove Hotel
19 min · Fire Island (Gay Beaches)Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 17.9 miles from Shirley
4.72 (1)
Hamptons Vacation Inn
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 17.5 miles from Shirley
4.92 (1)
Bayview Resort
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.
Instant booking
Hotel *** • 17.4 miles from Shirley
4.64 (1)
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Wi-Fi • Parking • Smoking allowed