Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Shirley

Stay where you never have to explain yourself

Keep searching in the city: Trusted gay-friendly stays

Gay travel is a niche market, which is why our inventory here is sometimes limited. By booking one of these LGBTQ+ friendly stays, you directly help misterb&b fund its mission: recruiting new gay hosts and covering the complex legal and regulatory costs we face. Give your stay meaning - book your favorite below!

Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.

1 Block to Bellport Bay! Scenic Hamptons Hideaway

Instant booking

Entire place • Shirley

1 Block to Bellport Bay! Scenic Hamptons Hideaway

3 Bedrooms • 4 Beds • 2 Bathrooms

Continue scrolling to discover more options.

Stays near Shirley

These stays match your search but are located outside Shirley.

Hosted by Benjamin

Instant booking

Entire place • 7.8 miles from Shirley

4.89 (1)

Dune Road House on Westhampton Beach

3 Bedrooms • 8 Beds • 3 Bathrooms

Hosted by Benjamin

Instant booking

Entire place • 18.5 miles from Shirley

4.9 (1)

Seaclusion Gardens in Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 2 Bathrooms

Hosted by Benjamin

Instant booking

Entire place • 17.6 miles from Shirley

4.85 (1)

Poolside Oasis in Ocean Bay

3 Bedrooms • 6 Beds • 2 Bathrooms

Hosted by Benjamin

Instant booking

Entire place • 17.9 miles from Shirley

4.81 (1)

Huron Hideaway in Ocean Bay

3 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 1 Bathroom

Hosted by Benjamin

Instant booking

Entire place • 17.9 miles from Shirley

4.62 (1)

Seaside Escape on Huron

5 Bedrooms • 7 Beds • 1 Bathroom

100

Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers

Instant booking

Ranked#1 Hotel

Hotel *** • 15.2 miles from Shirley

Booked 4 times

5 (4)

Grove Hotel

19 min · Fire Island (Gay Beaches)

Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only

100

Gay Welcoming ScoreRated by LGBTQ+ travelers

Instant booking

Private room • 14.2 miles from Shirley

Booked 2 times

5 (2)

The Madison Fire Island Pines

7 min · Ice Palace (Gay Bars & Clubs)

Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only

100

Gay Welcoming Score

Rated by LGBTQ+ travelers

Instant booking

Private room • 13.7 miles from Shirley

Booked 1 time

5 (1)

The Pines Men-Only Stay

15 min · Pavilion (Gay Bars & Clubs)

Gay District • Wi-Fi • Adult Only

Jeff·5·Sep. 2026· "It was amazing! Andre/Michael was a vary gracious host and is around all the time working on the property. He has put together an amazing and private get away. Not to mention he was the only place that you didnt have to book for 7 or 14 nights! We would have liked to have stayed longer but couldn't due to work."

Certified Gay-FriendlySigned a non-discrimination policy.