misterb&b logo
Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"Become a host
PrideGay Hotels
HomeĀ /Ā Gay Accommodations and B&bs in United StatesĀ /Ā Gay Accommodations and B&bs in Fire Island Pines

Search Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Fire Island Pines

alertPleaseselect datesto see availability and prices
See Ranking criteria
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Vincent
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ 11.9 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 4.94Ā (18)
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Clothing optional accepted ā€¢ Happy to share local tips ā€¢ LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Rooms near beach and train to NYC
Robert
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ 8 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (5)
Rooms near beach and train to NYC
Hot tub ā€¢ Parking ā€¢ Air conditioning
The poolhouse at Shady Walk
Alan
LGBTQ FlagEntire place ā€¢ Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (3)
The poolhouse at Shady Walk
Gay District ā€¢ Hot tub ā€¢ Pets allowed
#1 Hotel
Welcoming
Grove Hotel
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Hotel *** ā€¢ 1.2 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (4)
Grove Hotel
šŸ† Pride Points x2
Gay District ā€¢ Wi-Fi ā€¢ Adult Only
Seaclusion Gardens
Benjamin
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Entire place ā€¢ 4.7 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā New
Seaclusion Gardens
Gay District ā€¢ Air conditioning ā€¢ Kitchen
Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal
Robert
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ 8 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal
Hot tub ā€¢ Parking ā€¢ Air conditioning
Robbins Rest Retreat
Benjamin
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Entire place ā€¢ 5.2 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā New
Robbins Rest Retreat
Gay District ā€¢ Pets allowed ā€¢ Air conditioning
Welcoming
The Madison Fire Island Pines
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Private room ā€¢ Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (2)
The Madison Fire Island Pines
šŸ† Pride Points x0.5
Gay District ā€¢ Wi-Fi ā€¢ Adult Only
The Surfcomber Unit 2
Benjamin
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Entire place ā€¢ 3.8 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā New
The Surfcomber Unit 2
Gay District ā€¢ Pets allowed ā€¢ Air conditioning
Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views
Jon
LGBTQ FlagEntire place ā€¢ Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views
Gay District ā€¢ Air conditioning ā€¢ Kitchen
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
Benjamin
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Entire place ā€¢ 3.7 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā New
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
Gay District ā€¢ Pets allowed ā€¢ Air conditioning
Stay at Daddyā€™s House!!
William
LGBTQ FlagEntire place ā€¢ Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Stay at Daddyā€™s House!!
Gay District ā€¢ Dedicated workspace ā€¢ Air conditioning
Poolside Chic by the Sea
Benjamin
ApprovalĀ 
Instant
Entire place ā€¢ 3.8 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā New
Poolside Chic by the Sea
Gay District ā€¢ Air conditioning ā€¢ Kitchen
Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room
Vijay
Private room ā€¢ 1.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room
Gay District ā€¢ Breakfast included ā€¢ Hot tub
C1870ā€™s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Mark
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ 5.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
C1870ā€™s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Clothing optional accepted ā€¢ Happy to share local tips ā€¢ LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********
Giovanni
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ 10 miles from Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********
Clothing optional accepted ā€¢ Breakfast included ā€¢ Parking
Fire Island Pines, Room #5 - Exclusive For Gay Men
Michael
LGBTQ FlagPrivate room ā€¢ Fire Island Pines
ā˜…Ā 5Ā (1)
Fire Island Pines, Room #5 - Exclusive For Gay Men
Gay District ā€¢ Clothing optional accepted ā€¢ Happy to share local tips

Gay hotels around Fire Island Pines

New York Gay HotelsNewport Gay HotelsAtlantic City Gay HotelsProvidence Gay HotelsPhiladelphia Gay Hotels

More Gay hotels in United States

Provincetown Gay HotelsKey West Gay HotelsPhiladelphia Gay HotelsChicago Gay HotelsNew Orleans Gay Hotels

More Gay Accommodations and Gay Bnbs in United States

Gay Bnbs in San DiegoGay Bnbs in WashingtonGay Bnbs in DallasGay Bnbs in ChicagoGay Bnbs in West Hollywood
"Excellent" ontrustpilotrainbowLoved by 2M LGBTQ+ TravelerstrophyRewards Program
Help