Home / Fire Island

Search Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Fire Island

Stay where you never have to explain yourself

Gay accommodation tips for Fire Island

On my latest adventure to Fire Island, I explored sides of it I’d never imagined.

Hosted by VictorLikes Running, Pop, Video Games

Happy to share local tips

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Shared space: bedroom • West New York

4.89 (74)

Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Hosted by PaulLikes Fitness, TV Shows, Movies

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Freshly Updated!

Shared space: bedroom • Saddle Brook

4.93 (15)

Sunny Room in North Jersey

Clothing optional accepted • Dedicated workspace • Parking

Hosted by Christopher and MichaelLikes Movies, Exhibitions & Museums, TV Shows

Happy to share local tips

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Elmont

5 (28)

Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Hosted by VincentLikes Hiking, Exhibitions & Museums, Musicals

Happy to share local tips

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Private room • Shirley

4.94 (18)

Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Hosted by EliasLikes World Music, RnB & Soul, Astrology

Happy to share local tips

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Union City

New

Furnished Private Room Near Manhattan | Quiet Union City Stay

Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Dedicated workspace

Hosted by JorgeLikes Movies, Latin Music, Disco

Happy to share local tips

Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH

Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH

Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH

Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Jersey City

5 (13)

Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • Gym nearby

Hosted by AndresLikes Musicals, Pop, Theatre

Beautiful private room

Beautiful private room

Beautiful private room

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Union City

New

Beautiful private room

Clothing optional accepted • Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning

Hosted by Mike and DaveLikes Fitness, Theatre, Cooking

Happy to share local tips

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Norwalk

5 (15)

Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby

Hosted by KevinLikes Hiking, Wellness, Politics

All the Comforts of a Home

All the Comforts of a Home

All the Comforts of a Home

All the Comforts of a Home

All the Comforts of a Home

Freshly Updated!

Private room • New Haven

New

All the Comforts of a Home

Breakfast included • Dedicated workspace • Parking

Hosted by ChrisLikes Nudism, Dance & Electro, Astrology

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Lowerre

5 (14)

NYC Summer Reset | Pool • Cabana • Café • Patio

Clothing optional accepted • Gym nearby • Breakfast included

Hosted by BruceLikes Psychology, Politics, TV Shows

NYC Manhattan: Comfy Bed in Open Living Room - No Door (Host Present)

NYC Manhattan: Comfy Bed in Open Living Room - No Door (Host Present)

NYC Manhattan: Comfy Bed in Open Living Room - No Door (Host Present)

NYC Manhattan: Comfy Bed in Open Living Room - No Door (Host Present)

Freshly Updated!

Shared space: living room • Spuyten Duyvil

New

NYC Manhattan: Comfy Bed in Open Living Room - No Door (Host Present)

Clothing optional accepted • Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning

Hosted by DanyLikes Dance & Electro, TV Shows, Biking

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Private room • Union City

5 (6)

Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York

Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning • Kitchen

Hosted by FrankLikes Latin Music, Food & Wine, Wellness

Happy to share local tips

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Freshly Updated!

Private room • Roselle

New

Welcome to a cozy LGBTQI-friendly guest room in a unique movie-themed

Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Dedicated workspace

Hosted by Assaf

Beautiful Architecture&design

Beautiful Architecture&design

Beautiful Architecture&design

Beautiful Architecture&design

Beautiful Architecture&design

Private room • Newburgh

5 (8)

Beautiful Architecture&design

Parking • Air conditioning • Kitchen

Hosted by AntonioLikes Politics, Pop, World Music

Happy to share local tips

Private room • Brooklyn

4.67 (6)

Basic and Cozy

Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby

Hosted by Nelson

Happy to share local tips

Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan

Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan

Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan

Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan

Private room • New York

5 (10)

Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan

Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Air conditioning

Hosted by MichaelLikes Disco, Movies, Folk

Happy to share local tips

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Private room • Hazlet Township

5 (7)

Mike's Bed-and-Make-Your-Own-Damn-Breakfast

Clothing optional accepted • Happy to share local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby