Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
by 
Gay Accommodations & Gay Bnbs in Fire Island
Stay where you never have to explain yourself
Gay accommodation tips for Fire Island
Written by
Marc Dedonder
Marc Dedonder
January 1, 2026
On my latest adventure to Fire Island, I explored sides of it I’d never imagined.
Booked 94 times
4.89 (75)
Queen Bed, ClothingOptional, 15min from TimeSquare. Best views of NY
Clothing optional accepted • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Henry·5·Jul. 2026· "Victor and his flatmate were both easy to get along with. The place is very comfy and clean. Great comms! Thanks Victor 😀"
Hosted by Christopher and MichaelLikes Latin Music, Exhibitions & Museums, Movies
Happy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Freshly Updated!Booked 32 times
5 (28)
Large room / 20 min from NYC / Clothing optional
Clothing optional accepted • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Cory·5·Jun. 2026· "This was a great stay and a solid introduction to this app. The guys were very friendly and great hosts. I had good conversations with them but they were also alright letting me do my own thing as I came and went from the apartment. Would highly recommend staying here and I'll def look them up if I need a space in the area again"
Booked 32 times
4.93 (14)
Sunny Room in North Jersey
Clothing optional accepted • Wi-Fi • Dedicated workspace
Simun·5·May. 2026· "Though nestled in Saddle Brook, North Jersey, pretty far off from the usual NJ or NYC, surprisingly the place has its hidden gems - trails, parks, amenities and even Westfield Garden State Plaza where many restaurants and stores abound. Paul, the host, was kind enough to accommodate me on a few errands. Very responsive and helpful. His abode is equivalent to a local antique museum filled with many old portraits and small cars, a rare sight indeed. Would love to relish my memories on my next trip."
Booked 30 times
4.94 (18)
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Clothing optional accepted • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
Michael John·5·Jul. 2025· "Vincent and Jose were great hosts! They also had a very sweet canine ambassador representing the house. The space was perfect: nice size room, updated private bathroom, great back yard with a hot tub and a small above-ground pool, bed was comfy, and I was very well taken care of during my stay. I would definitely stay again and encourage others do the same."
Hosted by ZobaHappy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Private room • Brooklyn
New
Comfy Oasis in Brooklyn
LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby
Booked 28 times
4.95 (19)
Cozy Private Room in Jersey City – 5 min Walk to Journal Square PATH
Clothing optional accepted • Gym nearby
Ritz·5·Aug. 2026· "I loved the stay. Very clean place; warm & cordial hosts. It was more like visiting friends. The location is super convenient, close to journal sq PATH. Dogs are adorable. It was very easy to reach out to Jorge for questions and check in was no hassle. I highly recommend them as hosts & their place to try on."
Hosted by ZobaHappy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Private room • Brooklyn
New
Cozy Oasis in Brooklyn
LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby
Booked 23 times
5 (17)
Comfortable Room with Private Bathroom
Clothing optional accepted • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
William·5·Aug. 2026· "Mike and Dave (and Ouizi, too!) are fantastic 5* hosts - beautiful, historic home in the most lovely area of Norwalk with a view of the marina. Walking distance to an unlimited selection of venues for every choice of food, cocktails, live music, museums/aquarium, ... the list goes on. Such lovely guys and the sweetest pup every. Excited for a return visit soon to the Connecticut shore and all it has to offer from the perfect location and most comfortable home. An overall wonderful experience!"
Hosted by IsaiahLikes Dance & Electro, BikingHappy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Private room • New York
New
Private room in cozy Brooklyn apartment
Clothing optional accepted • Gym nearby
Booked 19 times
5 (16)
NYC Reset | Pool • Cabana • Massage • Breathwork • Hudson
Clothing optional accepted • Gym nearby • Wi-Fi
Lou·5·Aug. 2026· "I had a great stay at Chris's place. It's a good location to explore the Bronx. The bedroom is spacious, clean, and comfortable with an absolutely massive TV. Your area is sectioned off and surprisingly private. Chris himself is a wonderful guy. I spent some time with him by the pool and had some great conversation. I also took advantage of his massage, and it was legitimately one of the best massages I've had. I would definitely recommend the place to stay"
Hosted by Carlos
Entire place • East Hampton
New
The Crystal Forest House | Heated Pool & Garden
4 Bedrooms • 5 Beds • 5 Bathrooms
Booked 17 times
5 (9)
Super Cozy Apartment with a cute host and dog
Clothing optional accepted • Gym nearby
Rick·5·Jul. 2026· "Our stay was amazing! Kieran was really supportive from start to finish and always kept things laid back. It's also just a 15 min walk to a PATH station, which was ideal for hopping over to enjoy Pride in Manhattan.
Review from my bestie who was with me: "Cute host, cute dog, cute apartment, close to everything you need to be close to.""
Hosted by RushiHappy to share local tips
Happy to share local tips
Private room • Clifton
New
Stunning room for rent in Clifton NJ
Gym nearby • Parking
Booked 13 times
5 (7)
Cozy apart. With great view in Union City NJ a few mins from New York
Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning • Kitchen
Rolando·5·Jul. 2026· "My stay at Dany's place was great. He is a kind and friendly host. I'd definitely recommend him and would stay again at his apartment in my next NYC trip."
Booked 12 times
5 (8)
Beautiful Architecture&design
Parking • Air conditioning • Kitchen
Alex·5·Apr. 2024· "Assaf was so welcoming. Had a lovely stay. Beautiful area."
Booked 11 times
4.67 (6)
Basic and Cozy
LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby
Garland·5·Jul. 2025· "I really enjoyed my stay. Antonio was a great host! The closest subway station was just around the corner which was very convenient! The neighborhood was nice and quiet. I highly recommend this place."
Booked 11 times
5 (10)
Comfortable bedroom in Manhattan
LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Air conditioning
Bret·5·May. 2026· "Nelson is a great host with a nice and clean place. I enjoyed having a room to my own but also getting to make a connection. Though pretty far uptown, the apartment is very close to the subway and it was easy getting around."